As any voter who made it to the bottom of the recent ballot knows, there were City bond items and a bunch of City Charter amendments down there. So in this installment we’re going to review the results. And, since we’re almost two weeks out from the election we’re going to provide some analysis and historical context as well.
Also, for those looking for someone to blame for the slowness of the returns in Travis County, I would suggest looking at the City Council rather than County Clerk Dyana Limon-Mercado and her employees. That’s because the release of the early vote (always what is released first and indicative of the overall vote because it comes from the whole City and County) was delayed due to people still standing in line to vote. That might have been because a lot of people showed up late, but it’s also because of the length of the ballot.
Bonds
OK, Propositions A and B were bond items for parks and libraries respectively. Voters passed both by wide margins, 61% for parks and 60% for libraries. For more detail on the substance of these items you can refer to our pre-election account.
The message from voters regarding the bonds seems clear enough: Austin voters still love parks and libraries and are willing to continue funding them, even if Austin’s parks and libraries are facing some problems. The voters’ message on charter amendments, however, is more muddled — if indeed there was a message.
City Charter Amendments
There were eight charter amendments. Seven of those were put on the ballot by the Council and City staff, while Prop I made it to the ballot through a citizen petition drive. We’ll look at the ones from Council and staff first. For more detail you can review our pre-election story on the Charter amendments.
Of the seven charter amendments put on the ballot by Council and staff only two failed. Those were:
Prop D which proposed to eliminate the Charter requirement that the City Council meet once a week. 64% voted no.
Prop E which would have eliminated the Charter requirement that the Council set their rules by ordinance. That one went down 72%-28%.
One could read the rejection of these two items as a sign of distrust of the City Council — i.e. lack of trust in them being able to take a week off from meetings or wanting to make sure they show up for work (although the Council can just vote to cancel as many meetings as they please) and suspicion that they would abuse the rules if they were not required to pass them by ordinance.
But, voters also approved two Charter amendments that dramatically increase the Council’s powers; and, one of those simultaneously weakens the power of citizen petition initiatives — which have a long tradition in Austin.
Plus, voters approved an amendment that was something of a Rorschach test on whether voters trust or don’t trust City Council and City Management. That was Prop J. Let’s review Prop J next, along with a couple of non-controversial propositions. Then we’ll come back to the ones that increased Council powers.
Prop J. This proposition asked for voter permission to make “non-substantive corrections of typographical errors, punctuation, and sentence structure, and to change or remove language that is moot or unenforceable because it has been superseded by state law or by a final court order.” So this seemed like one where if voters don’t trust City government they would vote no —saying, “no you can’t decide what are typos.” In contrast if they trust City government they would say, “sure, go ahead.”
Voters rolled that one through with 72% in favor.
Also, as we noted in our pre-election coverage, former County Judge and Council critic Bill Aleshire maintains that the City plans to make substantive changes. A lawsuit is a potentiality here.
Meanwhile, two other housekeeping measures failed to arouse any suspicions and passed overwhelmingly.
Prop C, which related to the Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission (ICRC), 68% in favor, and
Prop F, which changed a reporting date for campaign contributions and clarified “the meaning of the term ‘election.’” It pulled 74%.
Now, let’s take a quick look at the two props which increased Council powers.
Prop H transfers the City Attorney from reporting to the City Manager to reporting to the Council as a whole. This is something that had been rejected repeatedly by voters in the past. But, Charter amendments are not like playoffs series in sports. It’s not two out of three or best out of seven. People trying to get a Charter change only have to win once and it becomes part of the Charter. (See single member districts which failed six times [since 1973] before voters passed it in 2014.)
Charter amendments are not like playoffs series in sports. It’s not two out of three or best out of seven. People trying to get a Charter change only have to win once . . .
The final score on this one was 65% yes to 35% no.
Prop G was the Charter amendment that most blatantly removes citizen power. It passed with almost 64% of the vote. It states that elections resulting from citizen petition drives must now be held only in November of even numbered years.
Petition drives to force elections on controversial issues have a long tradition in Austin — although they have been used sparingly, as opposed, for example, to citizen petitions in California. Until now, in accordance with state law, the Council set petition-driven elections for the next available state-allowed election date in Texas. That allowed for a certain immediacy in dealing with the particular issue in question. Under what voters passed on November 3, an election resulting from a citizen petition drive would have to wait until November of an even numbered year, even if was a very pressing and important issue in an odd numbered year.
This Charter change could draw a legal challenge claiming that only allowing petition elections to be held in November is not in compliance with state law. Barring such a legal challenge being successful citizen petition elections will only be held in November of even numbered years, along with City elections.
The most obvious reason Council wanted this change to happen is so that they will only have to deal with the annoyance of citizen petitions — and the accompanying challenge to Council power — every two years, at the most. Second the time lag might help kill whatever the initiative is. But, there is one more likely reason driving this change.
Republicans have started to utilize the petition and referendum part of the City Charter; one Republican in particular. There I’m referring to Matt Mackowiak and the group he leads, Save Austin Now. Save Austin Now first conducted a petition drive that resulted in voters reinstating the “camping ban” in 2021. That overturned the 2019 repeal of the camping ban by a Council supermajority — led by then Council Member/now Congressman Greg Casar.
Next Mackowiak led a petition driven that would have required Austin to have two sworn police officers per 1,000 residents. Voters rejected this one; evidently having examined it and decided it would be too costly and take away budgetary powers from the City Council.
Some might see these two elections as an example of how Austin voters examined issues closely, thought through them and came to prudent decisions. But, that is evidently not the thinking on the City Council. So now, barring a successful legal challenge, the right of Austin citizens’ to petition their local government has been seriously weakened.
And why do Democrats prefer even numbered Novembers? That’s when they can muster huge turnouts; even though City elections are not intended to be partisan. That has never been entirely the case, at least during the modern era. But, the insertion of party politics into City elections has dramatically increased in roughly the last 10 years.
On a personal note, as with many people who have been active in Austin politics, I have been on both the winning and losing side of petition and referendum elections. But, I always felt that the months long petition process, the challenges of conducting a petition drive, and then the debate once the item went on the ballot, all contributed to a deeper public understanding of the issue in question. So whether I was on the winning or losing side it felt like real democracy in action.
That may sound wistful, but to me it’s another part of sound local governance breaking loose and floating away.
Prop I
Speaking of petition drives and citizen initiatives, let’s move on to Prop I, which failed by 55% to 45%. This was the proposal, initiated by Save Austin Now, which would have required the City to hire an independent (of the City) auditor to review City finances, at least every five years.
There were rational arguments on both sides of Prop I that deserved a good public discussion. For instance as Save Austin Now launched its petition drive, Mayor Kirk Watson proposed that the City conduct a similar audit, but not put the requirement in the City’s governing document. Proponents of Prop I, however, pushed ahead arguing that City financial performance is off the rails and needs a clearly independent audit. They also questioned whether the City could be trusted to continue audits without a requirement in the Charter.
This could have been an item that benefitted from a serious and frank public discussion. The discussion would have likely gotten heated at times, but varying positions could be evaluated and that might help voters come to a reasoned decision — especially given that the item was near the bottom of a crowded November ballot with federal, state and county races all coming before Prop I. But, none of that took place.
Instead a group of local officials and activists, led by Congressman/former Council Member Greg Casar, labeled the Prop I proposal as a local version of DOGE, the Trump administration’s early second term effort to slash federal spending, led by Elon Musk and his chainsaw.

The only problem with this strategy was that it bore no relationship to the truth. As we discussed in a pre-election story, in DOGE Musk was empowered to make cuts on his own and he certainly didn’t do an audit before slashing into the federal budget and the workforce. With Prop I the outside auditors would have had no power whatsoever to make cuts. They could only suggest cuts or identify areas for potential cuts. The City Council would be the only ones who could actually make cuts.
Prop I failed with 55% voting no and 45% voting yes, 185,944 votes to 150,400.
Casar also said that the people who brought Prop I forward “hate Austin.”
In stopping the requirement for an outside audit of City spending Casar headed off the Council supermajority from added financial scrutiny. He may have also headed off financial scrutiny that could have touched on some of the spending and spending habits that began during his Council years.
Another speaker at the anti-Prop I rally was Louis Malfaro, Executive Director of the Travis County Democratic Party. Malfaro got right to his core message, “I’m here to let you know Democrats are against Prop I.” This could of course be read as you’re not a Democrat if you’re for Prop I.
This is a lot of Democratic party involvement in Austin politics, particularly by the leaders of the Travis County Democratic Party. So it seems like they should begin to take some responsibility for how Austin is governed, or mis-governed, but don’t count on it happening voluntarily.
I know that many Democrats consider it a canard when Republicans talk about “Democrat-run cities.” And, I know that Republican policies at the state and national level contribute to many of the problems that cities face. But, Democrats can’t completely escape responsibility. At least they should not be able to — when they hold every elected position in a City and County and get involved in City Charter amendments as well — even though the City Charter designed Austin government to be nonpartisan.
Coming next: Review and analysis of Council election results and a look at the upcoming runoffs.
* Note: Some media reports on election results only listed Travis County numbers. But, the City of Austin also has voters in Williamson and Hays Counties. They voted in all the bonds and proposition elections and part of District 8 is also in Hays County. Our numbers and percentages include figures from all three counties.
Correction: This story was corrected to state that the requirement that petition elections be held on the first available election date is a state law, not part of the City Charter.
___________________________
Folks: The Austin Independent is free to everyone who wants to read it, but it still takes money to publish and to research. You will be very hard pressed to find the kind of local journalism that the Austin Independent provides anywhere else. So please chip in on our Donate page and help us keep turning out stories.
If you happen to have difficulty on the Donate page please contact us here. Thank you.
The Austin Independent, a publication of The Austin Independent, LLC
All Rights Reserved
